The Paris AtlasCharting the artists, works, and places worth returning to.
  • Muse
· British · 1891–1938

Lady Duff Twysden

The Englishwoman Hemingway took to the 1925 Pamplona fiesta and turned into Lady Brett Ashley — and who spent the rest of a short life somewhere other than the novel that made her famous.

Details

Lived
1891–1938
Born
22 May 1891
Birthplace
Yorkshire, England
Died
27 June 1938 · aged 47
Place of death
Santa Fe, New Mexico
Nationality
British
Roles
Muse
Also known as
Mary Duff Stirling Smurthwaite · Dorothy Smurthwaite · Duff Stirling · Duff King

About Lady Duff Twysden

Lady Duff Twysden was born in Yorkshire in 1891 and christened Dorothy Smurthwaite. After her parents divorced she restyled herself Mary Duff Stirling, took the Scottish family name she preferred, and kept the name Duff for the rest of her life. She was educated partly in Paris and presented at court. In 1914 she married Edward Luttrell Grimston Byrom; he petitioned for divorce the following year, and in January 1917 she married Sir Roger Thomas Twysden at Edinburgh, which is where the title came from. Their son Anthony, born in 1918, later became the eleventh baronet.

The marriage went badly and she left it. By the early 1920s she was in Paris with her cousin Pat Guthrie, living in Montparnasse on very little money, wearing a man's felt hat and her hair cut short. In July 1925 she went to the Festival of San Fermín at Pamplona in a party that included Ernest Hemingway and his wife Hadley Richardson, Harold Loeb, Guthrie, and Donald Ogden Stewart. Loeb had spent a week with her on the coast shortly before; Guthrie was her companion; Hemingway was attracted to her and challenged Loeb to a fight over her during the week. Days after it ended Hemingway began writing, and the quarrel became the plot of The Sun Also Rises.

She never answered the portrait in print. Her divorce from Sir Roger came through in 1926, the year the novel was published, and she later married the American painter Clinton King. They lived in Mexico for a time, then moved to New York and settled in Santa Fe, New Mexico, where she died of tuberculosis on 27 June 1938 at forty-seven. Hemingway told interviewers a story about her funeral — pallbearers who had all been her lovers, a dropped coffin — which biographers have since shown he invented. She was cremated.

Life events

  1. 1891

    Born in Yorkshire and christened Dorothy Smurthwaite.

  2. 1914

    Marries Edward Luttrell Grimston Byrom, who petitions for divorce the next year.

  3. 1917

    Marries Sir Roger Thomas Twysden at Edinburgh in January, becoming Lady Twysden. Their son Anthony is born the following year.

  4. 1920s

    Leaves the marriage and settles in Montparnasse with her cousin Pat Guthrie, short of money and known across the Quarter's cafés.

  5. 1925

    Goes to the fiesta at Pamplona in July with Hemingway, Hadley Richardson, Harold Loeb, Guthrie, and Donald Ogden Stewart. Hemingway begins the novel days later.

  6. 1926

    Divorced from Sir Roger Twysden. The Sun Also Rises is published in October, and Montparnasse recognises her in Brett Ashley immediately.

  7. 1938

    Dies of tuberculosis at Santa Fe, New Mexico, on 27 June, aged forty-seven.

Featured in these books

Cover of The Sun Also Rises by Ernest Hemingway

The Sun Also Rises

by Ernest Hemingway

How Lady appears in its pages: Married twice, waiting on a divorce, magnetic to every man in the book — the center of gravity the whole novel orbits.

Read the character guide

People they knew

Documented connections — every one carries its source.

Illustrated portrait of Ernest Hemingway

Ernest Hemingway

  • Author
  • Journalist

Met

Known to each other in Montparnasse and together in the Pamplona party of July 1925, with Hemingway's wife Hadley Richardson also present. He began the novel days after it ended.

Wikipedia — Duff Twysden

Questions about Lady Duff Twysden

Who was Lady Duff Twysden?

A British woman, born Dorothy Smurthwaite in Yorkshire in 1891, who lived in Montparnasse in the 1920s and was the model for Lady Brett Ashley in Ernest Hemingway's The Sun Also Rises. The title came from her second marriage, to Sir Roger Thomas Twysden.

Is Brett Ashley based on Duff Twysden?

Yes. Hemingway drew Brett Ashley closely from her after the July 1925 trip to Pamplona, where he, Duff Twysden, Harold Loeb, Pat Guthrie, and Donald Ogden Stewart spent the fiesta together. The jealousies of that week became the novel's plot, and everyone in Montparnasse recognised the portrait.

How did Duff Twysden die?

She died of tuberculosis in Santa Fe, New Mexico, on 27 June 1938, aged forty-seven. Hemingway later told a lurid story about her funeral, with former lovers as pallbearers dropping the coffin; it was untrue, and she was cremated.

Did Duff Twysden and Hemingway have an affair?

There is no good evidence that they did. Hemingway was attracted to her and quarrelled with Harold Loeb over her at Pamplona, but Duff Twysden was travelling with Pat Guthrie, and Hemingway's wife Hadley Richardson was in the party. The novel gives Jake Barnes a longing it never lets him act on.

What happened to Duff Twysden after The Sun Also Rises?

Her divorce from Sir Roger Twysden was finalised in 1926, and she later married the American painter Clinton King. They lived in Mexico, then New York, and settled in Santa Fe, where she died in 1938. She never published a reply to the novel.

Sourced claims

Every connection the graph holds for Lady, with the evidence behind it.

Met

Ernest Hemingway

Known to each other in Montparnasse and together in the Pamplona party of July 1925, with Hemingway's wife Hadley Richardson also present. He began the novel days after it ended.

Wikipedia — Duff Twysden

Depicted in

The Sun Also Rises

Lady Brett Ashley is drawn from her, closely enough that Montparnasse recognised the portrait on publication. She was in the Pamplona party of July 1925 whose quarrels became the novel's plot.

Wikipedia — Duff Twysden; Harold Loeb, The Way It Was (1959)