Helen Rolt
A nineteen-year-old widow rescued from a torpedoed ship whose need for safety becomes entangled with Scobie’s need to be needed.
To be chosen openly and given a secure life after the sudden destruction of her marriage and journey.
The book
At a glance
- Nineteen
- Newlywed widow and shipwreck survivor
- Scobie’s lover
- Does not share Scobie’s Catholic belief
- A stamp album connected to Scobie’s daughter
Who they are in the book
Spoiler-freeHelen is nineteen and has been married only briefly when a German submarine sinks her ship and kills her husband. She reaches the colony as a survivor and new widow with very little emotional or practical protection. Scobie helps care for the survivors and is drawn to the mixture of youth, exhaustion, and defiance he sees in her.
Their relationship begins with attention and shared loneliness, then becomes an affair. Helen does not share Scobie’s Catholic beliefs and cannot understand why he will neither divorce Louise nor simply choose one relationship openly. She wants proof that he loves her, while he offers promises that keep both relationships in place.
Scobie often describes Helen as someone he must protect, but she makes choices and sees problems he avoids. She becomes jealous and angry, yet also offers to leave when she understands what the divided life is doing to him. His belief that she cannot survive abandonment says as much about his need to rescue people as it does about Helen.
How the book draws them
- A very young widowAt nineteen, Helen is legally an adult but much younger than Scobie. The short marriage and shipwreck have pushed her abruptly into grief and dependence.
- PlainspokenShe asks what Scobie means, challenges his divided promises, and resists the religious explanations that make no sense to her.
- Guarded by defianceHer sharpness and impatience protect her from appearing helpless. Scobie often responds by feeling more responsible for her.
- Jealous of the marriageLouise’s return makes clear that Helen will always be kept outside the official life Scobie refuses to leave.
- Able to offer departureHelen eventually suggests leaving the colony. That offer contradicts Scobie’s fixed belief that only his death can free her.
- Seen through Scobie’s needThe narration gives more room to his pity than to her grief. Readers have to distinguish Helen’s actions from the helpless figure he imagines.
Helen remains caught between Scobie’s promises and his refusal to leave Louise. She offers to go, but Scobie continues to believe that only his own disappearance can prevent her suffering. His suicide leaves her without explanation or the future he imagined he was giving her.
The closing pages show Helen drinking and moving toward a bleak sexual relationship with Bagster. This is not proof that Scobie was right about her helplessness. It shows that his secret death did not heal the grief, dependency, or isolation he helped deepen.
If you like The Heart of the Matter
If you like Graham Greene
Explore authors with a similar voice, perspective, and influence.
Louis-Ferdinand Céline
The doctor of the Paris slums who wrote the century's blackest, funniest novel — and changed the sound of French prose.
View author
Martha Gellhorn
War correspondent who covered the Spanish Civil War, D-Day, and conflicts across five more decades; Hemingway's third wife, 1940–1945.
View author
George Orwell
English novelist, essayist and journalist, born Eric Arthur Blair, who wrote Animal Farm and Nineteen Eighty-Four. He was an imperial policeman in Burma, a plongeur in Paris kitchens off the rue Mouffetard, and a militiaman shot through the neck in Spain before any of it.
View author