Nothing Personal
Baldwin's other book-length collaboration, made with the photographer Richard Avedon in 1964.
Read our take
A Dialogue
by James Baldwin, Nikki Giovanni
James Baldwin was forty-seven, Nikki Giovanni twenty-eight. A London television studio, one evening in November 1971, and neither of them willing to let the other off easily.
- 1973
About James Baldwin
The story, briefly
Spoiler-freeThe transcript of the conversation between James Baldwin and Nikki Giovanni taped in London on 4 November 1971 for the Black television program Soul!, published by J. B. Lippincott in 1973 with a foreword by Ida Lewis and an afterword by Orde M. Coombs. The two poets and essayists — a generation apart — argue about men and women, church and rage, what a Black writer owes, and what America does to the people who love it. The broadcast aired on WNET that December; the book preserves the whole exchange.
The story, in more detail
Soul!, the Black arts program on public television, brought Baldwin and Giovanni together in a London studio on 4 November 1971. Baldwin was living in the South of France, the elder statesman of Black American letters; Giovanni was the fast-rising poet of the Black Arts generation, twenty-eight to his forty-seven.
The program aired the conversation that December. What makes it last is the friction: Giovanni pushes Baldwin hardest on Black men and Black women — on what tenderness costs when the world humiliates a man at work — and Baldwin pushes back on rage, the church he left, and what a writer can actually change.
Lippincott published the full transcript in 1973 as A Dialogue, with the editor Ida Lewis introducing it and the writer Orde M. Coombs closing it. It reads in an evening, and it is one of the few places Baldwin's spoken voice — looping, courteous, sudden — survives on the page at length.
Themes and analysis
Two generations in one studio
Giovanni's reply about buying her own steak interrupts the assumption that a man's value at home depends on what he can provide. In the exchange quoted by Douglas Field, Baldwin makes household responsibility central to his sense of manhood; Giovanni refuses to make material dependence the condition of intimacy. Their disagreement turns an ordinary meal into a test of whose needs define a relationship. The younger speaker is not merely receiving the elder's wisdom: she forces an admired critic of domination to hear how his own terms can constrain another person.
The spoken exchange becomes a book
In the passage quoted by Stephen York, Baldwin makes a writer answerable not just for choosing words but for what those words do in other people's lives. Meaning is something to investigate and release, rather than a possession secured by eloquence. Read in a book built from conversation, that claim also invites readers to test the speakers' language against the person answering it. The dialogue becomes an encounter in which a compelling phrase cannot settle everything: its force depends on whether it opens understanding or leaves the other voice outside.
Why we recommend it
Baldwin talking is its own genre
The essays are composed; this is Baldwin thinking at speed against a sparring partner half a generation younger, and the rhythm of his talk survives the transcription.
It is short and it moves
A single evening's conversation, readable in one sitting — the fastest route into both writers' preoccupations in the early 1970s.
Giovanni holds the floor
This is not an interview. She interrupts, disagrees, and wins exchanges — the book is a dialogue in fact as well as title.
What this book explores
Timeline
November 1971
Baldwin and Giovanni record their conversation in London on 4 November for Soul!.
December 1971
WNET broadcasts the recorded conversation, reaching television viewers before the book edition.
1973
J. B. Lippincott publishes the transcript with a foreword by Ida Lewis and an afterword by Orde M. Coombs.
Book editions
- Hardcover
- J. B. Lippincott
- 1973
- 9780397009169
- Paperback
- J. B. Lippincott
- 1973
- 9780397009480
Reader reviews
Readers may also like
No Name in the Street
The long essay Baldwin published the following year, covering the same wounds in written prose.
Read our take
The Fire Next Time
The 1963 book whose arguments Giovanni tests him against, a generation on.
Read our takeA Dialogue: frequently asked questions
What is A Dialogue?
The published transcript of a conversation between the writers James Baldwin and Nikki Giovanni, taped in London on 4 November 1971 for the television program Soul! and published by J. B. Lippincott in 1973.
What do Baldwin and Giovanni talk about?
Black men and women, the church, rage and tenderness, the writer's responsibility, and America seen from a London studio — Baldwin from exile in France, Giovanni from the Black Arts generation coming up behind him.
Was the conversation broadcast?
Yes. It was taped for Soul!, the Black arts program on public television, and aired on WNET in December 1971. The book prints the exchange in full.
How long is it?
A single evening's conversation — the book reads in one sitting. It is the least demanding entry point into either writer's thinking from these years.
Who wrote the foreword and afterword?
The foreword is by Ida Lewis and the afterword by the essayist Orde M. Coombs. Both frame the conversation as a meeting of two generations of Black American writing.
If you like James Baldwin
Explore authors with a similar voice, perspective, and influence.
Louis-Ferdinand Céline
The doctor of the Paris slums who wrote the century's blackest, funniest novel — and changed the sound of French prose.
View author
Henry Miller
The Brooklyn dropout who arrived in Paris broke at thirty-eight and wrote the exuberant, banned books that ended American censorship.
View author
Ernest Hemingway
Author of The Sun Also Rises and A Moveable Feast; his pared-down style, developed in 1920s Paris, became the most imitated in American prose.
View author
References
References
The sources below include the primary text, editions, scholarship, archival materials, and other records that informed this page. They document A Dialogue, its publication, and its place in literary history.
1A Dialogue
NovelJames Baldwin, Nikki Giovanni, 1973Used forThe primary text represented by this page, used for descriptions of the work’s contents and for any quoted passages shown here.
2All Those Strangers: The Art and Lives of James Baldwin — introduction
NonfictionOxford University Press, 2015Used forIntroduction, pp. 9–10: quoted exchange on household responsibility and Giovanni's reply about the steak. Analysis uses these reproduced passages; the complete printed dialogue and broadcast were not independently collated.
3For Such a Time as This: The Influence of African American Holiness-Pentecostalism on James Baldwin as a Witness, Author, Prophet, and Leader in American Culture
WebsiteColgate Rochester Crozer Divinity School / University of Rochester repository, 2020Used forp. 75, note 182: quoted passage on writing, citing A Dialogue (1973), p. 83. Analysis uses these reproduced passages; the complete printed dialogue and broadcast were not independently collated.
4James Baldwin papers, 1936–1992 (Sc MG 936), finding aid
ArchiveSchomburg Center for Research in Black Culture, The New York Public LibraryUsed forUsed to place A Dialogue within James Baldwin's published work and verify its bibliographic context.
5Chicago Public Library — James Baldwin Biography
WebsiteUsed forUsed for independent biographical, archival, or historical context surrounding James Baldwin's career and the period in which A Dialogue appeared.
6Baldwin in France
WebsiteNational Museum of African American History and CultureUsed forUsed to cross-check authorship, chronology, and the work's place in James Baldwin's wider catalogue.
7Baldwin, James Arthur
WebsiteThe Martin Luther King, Jr. Research and Education Institute, Stanford UniversityUsed forUsed to verify James Baldwin and Nikki Giovanni's bibliography and place A Dialogue within the broader chronology of James Baldwin and Nikki Giovanni's career.
i
Why these sources are here
The primary text is the baseline reference for every book page. Additional references document publication history, interpretation, and historical context where that evidence is available.
Explore more resources