The Paris AtlasCharting the artists, works, and places worth returning to.

Fairy Tales Told for Children: First Booklet

Eventyr, fortalte for Børn. Første Hefte

by Hans Christian Andersen

Four tales in a 61-page booklet: a soldier with a magic tinderbox, a pea under twenty mattresses, and a reviewer who hoped Andersen would stop.

Published
1835
Pages
61
Setting
Era
Shelf rating
4.3

About Hans Christian Andersen

Illustrated portrait of Hans Christian Andersen

The story, briefly

Spoiler-free

Hans Christian Andersen's first booklet of fairy tales came out in Copenhagen on 8 May 1835, a month after his novel The Improvisatore. The bookseller C. A. Reitzel published it as a 61-page booklet costing 24 skilling. The booklet held four tales: The Tinderbox, Little Claus and Big Claus, The Princess and the Pea, and Little Ida's Flowers. Andersen had heard the first three as a child. Little Ida's Flowers was his own. He called the series Fairy Tales Told for Children, and five more booklets followed, the last in 1842.

The story, in more detail

Andersen was twenty-nine and hoping to be known as a novelist. In a letter of March 1835 to his friend Henriette Wulff, he said he had just written some fairy tales. He passed on what the physicist Hans Christian Ørsted had told him: The Improvisatore might make him famous, but the fairy tales would make him immortal. Andersen wrote that he did not agree.[1]

Years later he explained where the four tales came from. The first three were stories he had heard as a boy, in the spinning room and at the hop harvest. Little Ida's Flowers began on a visit to the writer Just Mathias Thiele. Andersen told Thiele's daughter Ida about the flowers in the botanical garden, and kept some of her remarks when he wrote the story down.[1]

He wanted the tales to sound spoken. In his autobiography he said he wrote them down in the words he used when telling them aloud to children, and called them "told for children" to quiet the critics. He meant them for young and old alike.[2] The booklet sold for a quarter of a rigsdaler, the Danish currency of the day. The Andersen Centre puts that at about five US dollars now.[1]

What's inside

The Tinderbox opens the booklet. A soldier walking home from the war meets a witch, who sends him down inside a hollow tree to fetch an old tinderbox. Down there, three dogs sit on chests of copper, silver and gold. Their eyes are as big as saucers, as big as millstones, and as big as the Round Tower in Copenhagen. The soldier keeps the tinderbox. Striking it calls the dogs, and he uses them to fetch a sleeping princess to his room at night.[3]

Little Claus and Big Claus is a comic tale about two farmers with the same name. Big Claus owns four horses and Little Claus owns one. On Sundays Little Claus borrows all five to plough, and he cannot stop shouting "Gee-up, my five horses!" Big Claus kills his one horse to shut him up. Little Claus sells the hide, and a string of lucky lies makes him rich. Every time Big Claus copies him, it goes badly for Big Claus.[3]

The Princess and the Pea is barely a page long. A prince wants to marry a real princess. On a stormy night a soaking-wet girl knocks at the town gate and says she is one. The old queen puts a single pea under twenty mattresses and twenty feather beds. In the morning the girl says she hardly slept and is black and blue all over, so she must be real.[3]

Little Ida's Flowers closes the booklet. Ida's flowers have wilted, and a student who is good at stories tells her why. They were at a ball all night, he says, dancing in the king's summer castle while everyone slept. That night Ida gets up and watches her own flowers dance.[4]

Themes and analysis

These readings discuss events throughout the book, including its ending.

A review that asked him to stop

Andersen remembered only one review, and it was not kind. In 1836 Dannora, a journal edited by J. N. Høst, said the tales might amuse children but taught them nothing. The reviewer was shocked that a princess in The Tinderbox rides to a soldier on a dog's back and is kissed. He found The Princess and the Pea "not only as indelicate but positively without excuse". He ended by hoping Andersen would waste no more time writing fairy tales.

Others were no more encouraging. One monthly journal complained that the author of The Improvisatore had fallen back on something so childish. Some friends told him he had no talent for tales. Others told him to study the French fairy tale first. Andersen wrote that he would willingly have stopped, "but they forced themselves from me."

Old stories and one new one

Andersen compared his method to that of Johann Karl August Musäus, a German writer of folk tales. Like Musäus, he retold old stories he had heard as a child, but in his own manner. The Tinderbox, Little Claus and Big Claus and The Princess and the Pea were the retellings. The Princess and the Pea ends with a joke about its own truth. The pea goes into the museum, "where it may still be seen if no one has stolen it."

Little Ida's Flowers was the only tale in the booklet Andersen made up himself. He admitted it was fairly close to a story by the German writer E. T. A. Hoffmann, and that he had already sketched it in an earlier book. Readers liked it best of the four, he said. After that he mostly invented his tales himself.

The tales in Paris

Andersen had spent the summer of 1833 in Paris on a travel grant from the Danish king, two years before the booklet appeared. The tales reached Paris in French later. In 1856 the Paris publisher Hachette brought out Contes d'Andersen, translated from the Danish by David Soldi, with a biographical notice by the critic Xavier Marmier.

All four tales from the first booklet are in the second edition of 1862. The Tinderbox became Le Briquet, and Little Claus and Big Claus became Petit Claus et grand Claus. The Princess and the Pea became La Princesse sur un pois, and Little Ida's Flowers became Les Fleurs de la petite Ida. The cartoonist Bertall drew forty small pictures for that edition.

Quotes from Fairy Tales Told for Children: First Booklet

Quoted verbatim from the text, each line verified against its source.

The one with eyes like saucers, the one with eyes like millstones, and the one whose eyes were as big as the Round Tower.
Hans Christian Andersen, "The Tinderbox" (1835), trans. Mrs. E. Lucas (1899)
So the prince took her to be his wife, for now he was sure that he had found a real princess, and the pea was put into the Museum, where it may still be seen if no one has stolen it.
Hans Christian Andersen, "The Princess and the Pea" (1835), trans. Mrs. E. Lucas (1899)
the flowers have been to a ball last night, and therefore they droop so.
The student (dialogue) · Hans Christian Andersen, "Little Ida's Flowers" (1835), trans. Mary Howitt (1846)
I would willingly have discontinued writing them, but they forced themselves from me.
Hans Christian Andersen, The Story of My Life (New York: Hurd and Houghton, 1871)

Why we recommend it

  1. Where Andersen's fairy tales start

    The first four tales he published, in the order he chose. The Tinderbox is on page 1.

  2. Short enough to read in one sitting

    The whole booklet ran to 61 pages. The Princess and the Pea takes about a minute to read aloud.

  3. Funnier and rougher than their reputation

    Little Claus and Big Claus is a string of cheerful frauds. The reviewer of 1836 thought the booklet unfit for children.

  4. Free and out of copyright

    The Danish text is in the public domain, and so are the English translations by Mary Howitt (1846) and Mrs. E. Lucas (1899).

What this book explores

The people in its pages

All four tales use types rather than names: a soldier, a princess, two farmers called Claus. Ida is the exception. She is based on Ida Thiele, the daughter of Andersen's friend Just Mathias Thiele.

  • The soldier

    The Tinderbox. Walking home from the war with nothing, he gets rich from the witch's tree and spends it all.

  • Little Claus

    The poor farmer with one horse, who talks his way out of every disaster.

  • Big Claus

    The rich farmer with four horses, who keeps copying Little Claus and keeps paying for it.

  • The princess

    The Princess and the Pea. She arrives soaking wet in a storm and proves herself by being bruised by a pea.

  • Ida

    Little Ida's Flowers. A girl whose wilted flowers, a student tells her, have been dancing all night. Andersen based her on Ida Thiele, a friend's daughter.

Also in the book

  • The student

    Little Ida's Flowers. A young man who tells wonderful stories and cuts pictures out of paper. He explains the flowers' ball to Ida.

Bring it to book club

  • The soldier in The Tinderbox is the hero, but he does some ugly things. Did Andersen mean readers to like him?
  • Little Claus lies his way to a fortune. Why is the reader on his side?
  • The Princess and the Pea ends by claiming to be a true story. What is the joke?
  • The 1836 reviewer thought the tales were bad for children. Can you see his point?
  • Andersen wrote the tales to sound spoken. Which lines work best read aloud?

A complete discussion guide is on our editorial calendar. Join the letter to hear when it ships.

Inside the book

Selected works from this book, with notes on each.

The Tinderbox

Fyrtøiet. A soldier, a witch, three dogs with enormous eyes, and a princess carried off at night. Pages 1 to 16 of the first edition.

Little Claus and Big Claus

Lille Claus og store Claus. Two farmers with the same name, and a string of tricks that ends in the river. Starts on page 17.

The Princess and the Pea

Prindsessen paa Ærten. The shortest tale in the booklet, on pages 42 to 44. Also translated as The Real Princess.

Little Ida's Flowers

Den lille Idas Blomster. Andersen's own invention, told first to a real girl named Ida. Starts on page 45.

Timeline

  1. March 1835

    Andersen tells Henriette Wulff he has written some fairy tales, and that Hans Christian Ørsted thinks they will make him immortal.

  2. 8 May 1835

    C. A. Reitzel publishes Eventyr, fortalte for Børn. Første Hefte in Copenhagen, 61 pages, at 24 skilling.

  3. 16 December 1835

    The second booklet follows, with Thumbelina.

  4. 1836

    The journal Dannora reviews the booklet and hopes Andersen will stop writing fairy tales.

  5. 1842

    A second printing of the first booklet. A third follows in 1845.

  6. 1846

    Mary Howitt's Wonderful Stories for Children, including Little Ida's Flowers, is published in New York.

  7. 1856

    Hachette in Paris publishes Contes d'Andersen, translated by David Soldi.

Book editions

Paperback
Paperback
Danish
C. A. Reitzel
1835
Eventyr, fortalte for Børn. Første Hefte. Published 8 May 1835, 61 pages, price 24 skilling, printed by Bianco Luno & Schneider. Reprinted in 1842 and 1845. Pre-ISBN.
Hardcover
Hardcover
Wiley & Putnam, New York
1846
Translated by
Mary Howitt
Wonderful Stories for Children, which includes Little Ida's Flowers. Out of copyright. Project Gutenberg has the text as ebook 43600.
Hardcover
Hardcover
French
Hachette, Paris
1856
Translated by
David Soldi
Contes d'Andersen, with a notice by Xavier Marmier. The 1862 second edition contains all four tales from the booklet. Pre-ISBN.
Hardcover
Hardcover
J. M. Dent, London, and E. P. Dutton, New York
1899
Translated by
Mrs. E. Lucas
Fairy Tales from Hans Christian Andersen, illustrated by Thomas, Charles and William Heath Robinson. Includes The Tinder Box, Great Claus and Little Claus, and The Real Princess. Out of copyright; the quotations were checked against a scan of this translation.
Paperback edition cover
Paperback
Anchor Press
1983
ISBN-13
9780385189514
Translated by
Erik Christian Haugaard
The Complete Fairy Tales and Stories, 1,101 pages, with a foreword by Virginia Haviland. Contains every tale in the booklet.

Reader reviews

Loading reviews…

Fairy Tales Told for Children: First Booklet: frequently asked questions

When was The Princess and the Pea first published?

On 8 May 1835, in Copenhagen, in the first booklet of Hans Christian Andersen's Fairy Tales Told for Children. The Danish title is Prindsessen paa Ærten. The tale fills pages 42 to 44 of the 61-page booklet.

What was in Andersen's first book of fairy tales?

Four tales: The Tinderbox, Little Claus and Big Claus, The Princess and the Pea, and Little Ida's Flowers. The first three were stories Andersen had heard as a child. Little Ida's Flowers was his own.

Did Andersen make up The Tinderbox?

No. He said The Tinderbox, Little Claus and Big Claus and The Princess and the Pea were stories he heard as a boy, in the spinning room and at the hop harvest. He retold them in his own way.

How was the first booklet received?

Badly, by Andersen's account. The review he remembered, in the journal Dannora in 1836, said the tales taught children nothing and called The Princess and the Pea indelicate. Friends told him to give up fairy tales.

Why is The Princess and the Pea sometimes called The Real Princess?

Several old English translations used that title, including the one by Mrs. E. Lucas in 1899. The prince in the tale is looking for a "real" princess, and the queen's pea is the test.

Does the first booklet have a Paris connection?

Through its French translation. Hachette in Paris published David Soldi's Contes d'Andersen in 1856. The 1862 edition has all four tales, including La Princesse sur un pois. Andersen himself had visited Paris in 1833.

If you like Hans Christian Andersen

Explore authors with a similar voice, perspective, and influence.

  • Illustrated portrait of Louis-Ferdinand Céline

    Louis-Ferdinand Céline

    The doctor of the Paris slums who wrote the century's blackest, funniest novel — and changed the sound of French prose.

    View author
  • Illustrated portrait of Simone de Beauvoir

    Simone de Beauvoir

    French writer and philosopher whose novels, memoirs, and social analysis examined freedom, gender, responsibility, aging, and the material conditions that shape a life.

    View author
  • Illustrated portrait of Henry Miller

    Henry Miller

    The Brooklyn dropout who arrived in Paris broke at thirty-eight and wrote the exuberant, banned books that ended American censorship.

    View author
References

References

The sources below include the primary text, editions, scholarship, archival materials, and other records that informed this page. They document Fairy Tales Told for Children: First Booklet, its publication, and its place in literary history.

  1. 1abcThe Timetable Year By Year: A Chronology of Hans Christian Andersen's Life

    Website
    The Hans Christian Andersen Centre, University of Southern Denmark
    Used for

    Andersen's letters about the tales, Hans Christian Ørsted's remark, and the origins of each story.

    View source
  2. 2The Story of My Life

    Memoir
    Hurd and Houghton, 1871
    Used for

    Andersen's own account of the booklet, its title and the 1836 review.

    View source
  3. 3abcFairy Tales from Hans Christian Andersen, translated by Mrs. E. Lucas (Alice Lucas), illustrated by Thomas, Charles and William Heath Robinson — Internet Archive scan

    Novel
    J. M. Dent (London) and E. P. Dutton (New York), 1899
    Used for

    The public-domain English translation used for the plot and for quotations from The Tinderbox and The Princess and the Pea.

    View source
  4. 4Wonderful Stories for Children, translated from the Danish by Mary Howitt (Project Gutenberg ebook 43600)

    Novel
    Wiley & Putnam, New York, 1846
    Used for

    Mary Howitt's 1846 translation, used for Little Ida's Flowers.

    View source
  5. 5Eventyr, fortalte for Børn. Første Samling. Første Hefte. 1835 — register of works, no. 301

    Website
    The Hans Christian Andersen Centre, University of Southern Denmark, 1835
    Used for

    The Andersen Centre's record of the booklet: contents and publication date.

    View source
  1. 6H.C. Andersen Bibliografi: Digterens danske Værker 1822–1875 (online edition)

    Website
    The Hans Christian Andersen Centre, University of Southern Denmark, 1942
    Used for

    The standard bibliography of Andersen's Danish first editions: title page, publisher, page count, price, reprints and the page where each tale starts.

    View source
  2. 7Contes d'Andersen, trans. D. Soldi, with a biographical notice by X. Marmier (Paris: Hachette, 1856) — catalogue record

    Official record
    Bibliothèque nationale de France, 1856
    Used for

    The Bibliothèque nationale de France record of the first Hachette edition, Paris, 1856.

    View source
  3. 8Contes d'Andersen, 2nd edition, trans. D. Soldi, notice by X. Marmier, 40 vignettes by Bertall (Paris: Hachette, 1862) — digitised copy with table of contents

    Official record
    Bibliothèque nationale de France, Gallica, 1862
    Used for

    The 1862 second edition, whose table of contents gives the French titles of all four tales.

    View source
  4. 9The Complete Fairy Tales and Stories, trans. Erik Christian Haugaard (Anchor Press, 1983) — Open Library edition record

    Website
    Open Library, Internet Archive
    Used for

    Library record for ISBN 9780385189514, Erik Christian Haugaard's complete translation.

    View source
  5. 10Fairy Tales Told for Children: First Booklet

    Novel
    Hans Christian Andersen, 1835
    Used for

    The primary text represented by this page, used for descriptions of the work’s contents and for any quoted passages shown here.

i
Why these sources are here

The primary text is the baseline reference for every book page. Additional references document publication history, interpretation, and historical context where that evidence is available.

Explore more resources