The Nick Adams Stories

The arrangement, by critic Philip Young — whose wound-centered theory of Hemingway shaped a generation of readers — moves from 'Three Shots,' a frightened boy alone in a tent, through the doctor's-son stories, the hobo roads, the war and the famous unnamed wound, the fishing cures, and on to 'Fathers and Sons,' Nick driving with his own boy and circling his father's suicide. Read in this order, the cycle becomes what Young argued it always was: one story about damage and repair, told in installments across a career.

The additions carry the volume: fragments and complete pieces from the manuscripts, above all 'The Last Good Country' — a long, unfinished idyll-thriller of young Nick and his kid sister fleeing game wardens into the deep woods, tender in a register Hemingway rarely allowed himself — and 'On Writing,' the discarded ending of 'Big Two-Hearted River' in which Nick simply becomes the author, thinking about the very stories the reader has been reading. Purists objected — the chronology flattens deliberate ambiguities, and Hemingway never authorized any of it — but fifty years of readers have met Nick here first, and the cycle survives its editors.

Twenty-four pieces in the order of a life. The Northern Woods: 'Three Shots,' 'Indian Camp,' 'The Doctor and the Doctor's Wife,' 'The Last Good Country.' On his own: 'The Battler,' 'The Killers,' the road years. The war: 'Now I Lay Me,' 'A Way You'll Never Be,' the wound at the center of everything. Home again: 'Big Two-Hearted River' entire, the fishing trip as field surgery. Company of two: love stories and endings. And 'Fathers and Sons' to close — Nick as father, the cycle folding back on itself.

New readers: this is the best single door into Hemingway's stories. Returning readers: 'The Last Good Country' alone justifies the volume.