The Paris AtlasCharting the artists, works, and places worth returning to.
Cover of Juan Belmonte, Killer of Bulls by Manuel Chaves Nogales

Juan Belmonte, Killer of Bulls

Juan Belmonte, matador de toros

by Manuel Chaves Nogales

The matador who invented modern bullfighting tells his life to Spain's greatest reporter — night swims, secret capework in the dark, and the melancholy of surviving the golden age.

Published
1935
Setting
Spain
Shelf rating
4.6

About Manuel Chaves Nogales

Illustrated portrait of Manuel Chaves Nogales
Manuel Chaves Nogales

1 book on our shelves

The story, briefly

Spoiler-free

Juan Belmonte's life in his own voice: the poor kid from Triana who swam the Guadalquivir at night to fight bulls in secret, stood still when every expert said to run, and remade an art form — dictated to the journalist Manuel Chaves Nogales, whose prose makes it read like a novel. Widely called the best book ever written about bullfighting, and one of the best as-told-to books about anything. (A life story — its endings wait behind the reveal.)

The story, in more detail

This one is a genuine hidden classic. It's an as-told-to autobiography: the great Spanish journalist Manuel Chaves Nogales sat with Belmonte and wrote his life in the first person (Juan Belmonte, matador de toros, 1935; the English translation — done, wonderfully, by Leslie Charteris, the creator of The Saint — appeared in 1937 as Juan Belmonte, Killer of Bulls).

The material is almost implausibly good. Belmonte grew up poor in Triana, the flamenco quarter across the river from Seville, and learned to fight as a teenager by swimming the Guadalquivir at night with his friends to trespass on bull-breeding ranches — fighting the animals naked in the dark, because clothes would be evidence and moonlight was the only arena lighting they had. From there it follows him into the invention of modern bullfighting: Belmonte was ungainly, weak-legged, physically wrong for the job, so instead of dancing away from the bull he stood still and made the bull move around him — which experts initially called suicide and then called the revolution. The rivalry with Joselito, the golden age they shared until Joselito died in the ring in 1920, the fame, the strange melancholy of surviving — all of it is told with a dry, fatalistic Sevillian wit that reads like a novel.

Its reputation among people who know it: the best book ever written about bullfighting, and one of the best 'as-told-to' books ever written about anything — Chaves Nogales was a superb liberal journalist (exiled by the Civil War, died in London in 1944, hugely rediscovered in Spain in the 2000s), and his prose is why the book outlives its subject's sport. It pairs eerily with The Sun Also Rises, too: the aging Belmonte that Hemingway sketches at the 1925 feria is the same man who, ten years later, sat down and out-narrated everyone.

The full story

It begins across the river. Triana, Seville's flamenco quarter, the 1890s: Juan Belmonte is the small, sickly son of a shopkeeper, wrong in every physical particular for the only ambition available to a poor Andalusian boy. The famous early chapters follow him and his gang swimming the Guadalquivir at night to trespass on the bull-breeding ranches — capework by moonlight, naked because clothes left evidence — an apprenticeship conducted entirely in the dark, against the law, with animals that could kill them.

The revolution follows from the body he was stuck with. Too weak-legged to dance away from the bull like the classical masters, Belmonte stood his ground and made the bull do the moving — breaking the sport's oldest safety rule, working inside the animal's terrain, and turning what the experts called suicide into the foundation of modern bullfighting. One fights as one is, runs his famous aphorism, and the book is that sentence enacted: the deficiencies becoming the style, the style becoming the age. Fame arrives like weather — the alternativa, the mobbed seasons, the rivalry with the god-like Joselito that split Spain into two congregations and burned both men through a hundred corridas a year.

How it ends — spoilers aheadThe final movement, ending included. Open when you're ready.

The golden age ends in one afternoon: May 1920, at Talavera de la Reina, when Joselito — the complete matador, the one built for the job as Belmonte never was — is caught and killed in the ring at twenty-five. Belmonte inherits the summit alone, and the book's last movement is the strange melancholy of surviving: the retirements and comebacks, the fortune, the fame that outlived the joy of the thing itself, told with the dry Sevillian fatalism that makes the whole memoir feel like a novel. It closes in 1935 with its subject mid-life, master of an art he had permanently changed — and everything after, including the afternoon Hemingway caught at Pamplona in 1925 and the end at his own hand in 1962, lies outside its pages.

Why we recommend it

  1. A voice you don't forget

    The as-told-to form at its absolute peak: Belmonte's dry, fatalistic Sevillian wit, caught by a reporter good enough to disappear into it.

  2. The answer to Hemingway's afternoon

    The novel catches Belmonte old, sick, and jeered; the memoir gives him the last word — and it turns out the matador could out-narrate the novelists.

  3. History smuggled into a sports book

    Spain from the 1890s to 1935, one life wide — poverty, fame, and a country's golden age — by the reporter whose Civil War stories later made him a rediscovered classic.

What this book explores

The people in its pages

A memoir — everyone in these pages was real. Each face opens a spoiler-free guide; endings stay behind a warning.

  • Illustrated portrait of Juan Belmonte

    Juan Belmonte

    The subject and the voice — the matador telling his own life, from the moonlit river to the top of the golden age.

  • Illustrated portrait of Joselito

    Joselito

    The rival — a born matador from a great bullfighting dynasty, effortless where Belmonte was desperate. Between the two of them, they made the golden age.

Timeline

  1. 1935

    Manuel Chaves Nogales sets down the matador Juan Belmonte's life in the first person, published as Juan Belmonte, matador de toros.

  2. 1937

    Leslie Charteris, creator of The Saint, translates it into English as Juan Belmonte, Killer of Bulls.

  3. 2000s

    After half a century's neglect, Chaves Nogales is rediscovered in Spain, and the book now stands as a classic in both languages.

Book editions

Hardcover
Hardcover
1935
First Spanish edition — Juan Belmonte, matador de toros
Hardcover
Hardcover
1937
First English edition, translated by Leslie Charteris

Reader reviews

Loading reviews…

Cover of The Sun Also Rises by Ernest Hemingway

The Sun Also Rises

Ernest Hemingway

The novel that caught him mid-decline, under his own name — read the fiesta chapters, then hear the man himself.

Read our take

Recommended alongside Death in the Afternoon and The Dangerous Summer.

Juan Belmonte, Killer of Bulls: frequently asked questions

Who wrote Juan Belmonte, Killer of Bulls?

The Spanish journalist Manuel Chaves Nogales, who set down the matador Juan Belmonte's life in the first person. It was published in 1935.

What is Juan Belmonte, Killer of Bulls about?

The life of Juan Belmonte — the poor boy from Triana who swam the Guadalquivir at night to fight bulls in secret, stood his ground where every expert said to run, and remade the art of bullfighting.

Is it a novel or a real autobiography?

It is an "as-told-to" autobiography. Chaves Nogales sat with Belmonte and wrote his life in the matador's own voice, in prose that reads like a novel.

Why is it famous?

It is widely called the best book ever written about bullfighting, and one of the finest as-told-to books about anything.

How is it connected to the Lost Generation?

Belmonte is the matador the expatriates watched at Pamplona; he appears in Hemingway's The Sun Also Rises under his own name. This book is that world telling its story in its own voice.