Giovanni's Room
The other short one, and the other novel about a couple with nowhere to live — though nothing else about them matches.
Read our take
If Beale Street Could Talk
A nineteen-year-old in Harlem is pregnant, and the father of her child is in the Tombs for something he did not do.
- 1974
- 197
- Elegiac
- Melancholy
- voice-driven
- intimate
- lyrical
About James Baldwin
The story, briefly
Spoiler-freeJames Baldwin's fifth novel, published by Dial Press in 1974 and the shortest after Giovanni's Room. Tish Rivers is nineteen and pregnant. Fonny Hunt, the father, is twenty-two, a sculptor, and in jail on a rape charge brought on a false identification. The novel is narrated by Tish, and follows both families as they try to get him out before the baby arrives. Barry Jenkins filmed it in 2018.
The story, in more detail
If Beale Street Could Talk is the only one of Baldwin's novels narrated by a woman, and the warmest thing he wrote. He was in his fifties, living mostly at Saint-Paul-de-Vence in the south of France, and the anger of the late 1960s books had turned into something steadier.
The subject is a wrongful prosecution, and the novel is specific about the machinery: an identification made under pressure, a witness who leaves the country, a bail figure set beyond what two working families can raise, and a district attorney with no reason to move quickly. Nothing in it depends on a villain. The system works exactly as designed and that is the point Baldwin is making.
Barry Jenkins adapted it in 2018, and Regina King won the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actress for playing Tish's mother, Sharon. The film brought the novel a readership larger than it had in Baldwin's lifetime.
The full plot
Tish Rivers and Fonny Hunt grew up on the same Harlem blocks and have known each other since they were children. They are in love, they intend to marry, and they have been looking for a loft they can afford to live and work in — Fonny is a sculptor, which in 1970s New York is not a living.
Fonny is arrested and charged with the rape of a Puerto Rican woman, Victoria Rogers, on an identification she makes under considerable pressure from a police officer, Bell, who has already had a run-in with Fonny and has reason to want him gone. Fonny was across the city at the time, with Tish and a friend, but the alibi comes from people the court has no interest in believing.
Tish discovers she is pregnant and tells both families. Her own — her mother Sharon, her father Joseph, her sister Ernestine — close ranks around her. Fonny's mother and sisters, who are church people and have never approved of Tish, do not. Joseph and Fonny's father Frank start stealing from the garment district to raise money for lawyers and bail. Sharon flies to Puerto Rico to find Victoria and ask her, face to face, to look again at what she saw.
How it ends — spoilers ahead
Sharon finds Victoria in Puerto Rico and gets nowhere. The woman has been broken by what happened to her and by everything since, and she will not revisit the identification. Soon afterwards she disappears, which removes the prosecution's witness and also removes any prospect of a quick acquittal.
The trial is postponed. Fonny is eventually released on bail while it remains pending, and the case is never resolved on the page. Frank, who has been caught stealing and cannot see a way forward, dies. The novel ends with Tish going into labour and with Fonny back at work on his sculpture, waiting for a trial date. Baldwin gives them the child and withholds the verdict.
Quotes from If Beale Street Could Talk
I don’t want to sound foolish. But, just remember, love brought you here. If you trusted love this far, don’t panic now.
It’s a miracle to realize that somebody loves you.
Neither love nor terror makes one blind: indifference makes one blind.
Why we recommend it
The warmest book he wrote
Tish's family is drawn with real affection and real humour, and the novel is genuinely tender about young love in a way none of the earlier ones are.
It is specific about how it happens
The wrongful charge is not a plot device. Baldwin lays out the identification, the bail, the missing witness and the delays, and the machinery never needs a villain to work.
Two hundred pages
The shortest Baldwin after Giovanni's Room, and the easiest to finish in a sitting.
What this book explores
The people in its pages
Tish Rivers
Clementine, nineteen, and the narrator. Pregnant, working a perfume counter, and holding the whole thing together while the men are out raising money.
Fonny Hunt
Alonzo, twenty-two, a sculptor, and in the Tombs awaiting trial on a charge built from an identification he had nothing to do with.
Sharon Rivers
Tish's mother, forty-three, and the steady centre of the family. She flies to Puerto Rico to ask Fonny's accuser to look again at what she saw.
Joseph Rivers
Tish's father, a longshoreman, who starts stealing from the garment district with Frank Hunt to pay for lawyers and bail.
Ernestine Rivers
Tish's older sister. Once preoccupied with her appearance, now bookish and serious, working at a settlement house and running the campaign to get Fonny out.
Frank Hunt
Fonny's father, a former tailor whose shop went under. Not religious, unlike his wife, and the one member of that household who is on Tish's side.
Also in the book
Victoria Rogers
The young Puerto Rican woman whose identification puts Fonny in jail. Baldwin writes her as another person the system is using, not as a liar.
Officer Bell
The policeman who had already crossed Fonny once and had reason to want him gone.
Daniel Carty
Fonny's friend, out of prison himself, and one of the people whose word the court has no interest in believing.
Bring it to book club
- Tish narrates throughout. How would the book change if Fonny told it?
- Fonny's mother and sisters refuse to help. Is the novel fair to them?
- Baldwin ends without a verdict. Is that hopeful, bleak, or neither?
Timeline
1974
Dial Press publishes the novel.
2006
Vintage International issues the paperback that is now the standard edition.
2018
Barry Jenkins's film adaptation is released.
2019
Regina King wins the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actress for the film.
Book editions
Hardcover
- Hardcover
- Dial Press
- 1974
Hardcover
- Hardcover
- Michael Joseph
- 1974
- Paperback
- Vintage International
- 2006
- 9780307275936
- Hardcover
- Vintage International
- 2024
- 9780593688984
Reader reviews
Readers may also like
Go Tell It on the Mountain
The Harlem church families here are the ones from the first novel, twenty years on and seen from outside.
Read our take
Just Above My Head
The novel that followed, and the other late book that treats a family as something that can hold.
Read our takeIf Beale Street Could Talk: frequently asked questions
What is If Beale Street Could Talk about?
Tish Rivers, a fictional nineteen-year-old in Harlem, is pregnant. Fonny Hunt, the father of her child, is in jail awaiting trial on a rape charge based on a false identification. The novel follows Tish and both families as they try to get him released before the baby is born.
Is If Beale Street Could Talk based on a true story?
No. Tish, Fonny and the case are invented. The circumstances are not — Baldwin was writing about a pattern of wrongful prosecution he had reported on and argued about for two decades.
How does the book differ from the 2018 film?
Barry Jenkins's adaptation follows the novel closely, including Tish's narration. The main differences are compression: several family scenes are shortened, and the film gives more screen time to the friendship between Fonny and Daniel than the novel gives on the page.
Where does the title come from?
Beale Street in Memphis, the street associated with W. C. Handy and the early blues. Baldwin's epigraph broadens it, taking Beale Street to stand for every Black neighbourhood in the United States.
Is this a good first Baldwin novel?
Yes. It is short, it is narrated in a warm and direct voice, and it needs no context to work. Readers who found Another Country cold or Go Tell It on the Mountain dense often get on with this one.
Does the novel say whether Fonny is freed?
No. The trial is postponed and Fonny is released on bail while it remains pending, but the case is never resolved on the page. Baldwin ends with the birth instead.