
Tropic of Cancer
The next scandal printed in Paris because it could not be printed anywhere else — and Henry Miller's whole doctrine runs downstream of Lawrence.
Read our take
D. H. Lawrence's last novel: printed privately in Florence in 1928, reprinted cheaply in Paris in 1929 to beat the pirates, and legal in Britain only from 1960.
D. H. Lawrence's last novel, and the one that kept courts busy for thirty years. Constance Chatterley is married to Sir Clifford Chatterley, owner of the Wragby estate in the English Midlands, who came home from Flanders paralysed from the waist down. Her affair with Oliver Mellors, the estate's gamekeeper, is the scandal the book is remembered for; the book itself spends at least as much time on class, on the collieries eating the countryside, and on what Lawrence saw as a civilization gone dead from the neck down. No publisher would touch the unexpurgated text, so Lawrence printed it himself in Florence — and when the pirates moved in, he came to Paris.
Lawrence wrote the novel three times over, at the Villa Mirenda outside Florence between 1926 and 1928. The first version was published after his death as The First Lady Chatterley (1944); the second as John Thomas and Lady Jane (1972), a title he had once considered for the book itself. The third version is the novel as published — and no commercial publisher in London or New York would publish it as written.
So Lawrence became his own publisher. Through the Florentine bookseller Giuseppe Orioli he had 1,000 numbered, signed copies printed at the Tipografia Giuntina in July 1928, sold by subscription at £2, with the phoenix device stamped on mulberry-coloured boards. The edition sold out despite seizures in the post, and made him more money than anything he had written. It also made him a target: photographic piracies of the book appeared within months in America and Europe, priced high, paying him nothing.
That is what brought him to Paris in March 1929. He asked Sylvia Beach to publish a cheap authorized edition; she declined — she did not admire the book, and did not want Shakespeare and Company known as a publisher of erotica. The deal went instead to Edward Titus, the American bookseller-publisher at the Sign of the Black Manikin, 4 rue Delambre in Montparnasse. Lawrence's letter of 5 April 1929 set the terms: 3,000 copies at 60 francs, profits split. The Paris "Popular Edition" appeared within weeks, carrying a new introduction written for it, "My Skirmish with Jolly Roger" — Lawrence's account of the piracy war, later expanded into the essay "A Propos of Lady Chatterley's Lover." The imprint named no publisher at all: just "Privately Printed, 1929."
Britain and America read the book censored for a generation. The authorized 1932 editions from Martin Secker and Alfred A. Knopf were heavily expurgated. The full text became legal in America in 1959, when a federal court struck down the Post Office's mail ban on Grove Press's edition, and in Britain on 2 November 1960, when an Old Bailey jury acquitted Penguin Books under the new Obscene Publications Act. Penguin's 200,000-copy printing sold out on its first day.
Constance Reid marries Sir Clifford Chatterley in 1917, while he is home on leave; he returns to Flanders and is shipped back, in the novel's phrase, more or less in bits. Paralysed from the waist down, he settles at Wragby Hall, his seat in the coal-mining Midlands, and turns himself first into a fashionable writer and then into a hard-headed director of his collieries. Connie runs the house, listens to the talk of Clifford's intellectual guests, drifts into a brief unsatisfying affair with the playwright Michaelis, and slowly comes apart — until her sister and father insist she take exercise, and her walks begin to pass the gamekeeper's hut in the wood.
Oliver Mellors is the keeper: a collier's son who rose to lieutenant in India and came back to the woods, separated from a wife he cannot legally shed. The affair begins in the hut and grows over the spring and summer, chapter by chapter, in scenes whose sexual explicitness — and whose vocabulary — kept the full text unpublishable in Britain for thirty-two years. Around the wood, the novel keeps returning to Tevershall pit-village and the industrial Midlands, blotting out, as Lawrence writes, the agricultural England.
Connie becomes pregnant by Mellors and leaves for Venice with her sister, half-intending to pass the child off as another man's. The plan collapses when Mellors's estranged wife returns, finds evidence of the affair, and makes it a public scandal. Connie tells Clifford the truth and asks for a divorce; he refuses. The novel ends with the lovers apart and waiting — Connie expecting the child, Mellors working on a farm toward his own divorce — on the hope contained in the long letter from Mellors that closes the book.
Ours is essentially a tragic age, so we refuse to take it tragically. The cataclysm has happened, we are among the ruins, we start to build up new little habitats, to have new little hopes. It is rather hard work: there is now no smooth road into the future: but we go round, or scramble over the obstacles. We've got to live, no matter how many skies have fallen.
The world is supposed to be full of possibilities, but they narrow down to pretty few in most personal experience.
A woman has to live her life, or live to repent not having lived it.
The affair crosses the sharpest line in the book, which is not marriage but class: a baronet's wife and a collier's son. The Tevershall chapters, watching industrial England blot out the old, are as fierce as anything Lawrence wrote.
Florence subscription printing, Paris counter-piracy edition, two decades of expurgation, then the two court decisions that changed what could legally be printed in English. The book's publication is a story on the scale of its plot.
He defended the novel to the end — the essay that began as its Paris introduction argues the book's case in plain terms: tenderness taken seriously, the body trusted as much as the mind.
1926
Lawrence begins the novel at the Villa Mirenda, near Florence; he writes three complete versions by 1928.
1928
The third version is printed privately in Florence in July — 1,000 signed copies arranged through Giuseppe Orioli, sold by subscription at £2. Pirated reprints appear within months.
1929
Lawrence comes to Paris in March; Sylvia Beach declines the book, and Edward Titus issues the 3,000-copy Popular Edition at 60 francs, with "My Skirmish with Jolly Roger" as introduction.
1932
Authorized expurgated editions from Martin Secker in London and Alfred A. Knopf in New York — the only legal form of the book in either country for decades.
1944
The first version is published in New York as The First Lady Chatterley, with a foreword by Frieda Lawrence.
1959
Grove Press publishes the unexpurgated text in America; Judge Frederick van Pelt Bryan rules on 21 July that the book is not obscene and lifts the Post Office ban.
1960
R v Penguin Books at the Old Bailey, 20 October to 2 November. The jury acquits, and the 200,000-copy Penguin edition sells out on publication day.
1972
The second version is published as John Thomas and Lady Jane.
2024
The novel enters the United States public domain on 1 January; Project Gutenberg releases the full text in March.


The next scandal printed in Paris because it could not be printed anywhere else — and Henry Miller's whole doctrine runs downstream of Lawrence.
Read our take
The other unpublishable masterpiece issued privately for subscribers. Sylvia Beach published Joyce's; she turned Lawrence's down.
Read our take
Prosecuted in London the same year, 1928 — the other novel in that season's obscenity war, and the one that lost.
Read our take
Henry Miller's runaway attempt at a Lawrence study — the book that shows what Lawrence meant to the next Paris generation.
Read our take
Anaïs Nin's first book, a defense of Lawrence published in Paris in 1932 — by Edward Titus, the same man who issued this novel's Paris edition.
Read our takeD. H. Lawrence's 1928 novel follows Constance Chatterley, a fictional baronet's wife in the English Midlands, whose husband Sir Clifford came back from the First World War paralysed, and whose affair with the estate's gamekeeper, Oliver Mellors, crosses the class line the book cares about most. The sexual explicitness made it notorious; the argument underneath is about class, industry, and a war-damaged England.
For obscenity: the explicit sex scenes and their vocabulary. No British or American publisher would issue the full text in 1928, so Lawrence printed it privately in Florence. Authorized editions from 1932 were heavily expurgated, and the complete novel stayed illegal in Britain until a jury acquitted Penguin Books at the Old Bailey on 2 November 1960.
Penguin Books was prosecuted at the Old Bailey in October 1960 under the Obscene Publications Act 1959, the first major test of that law's literary-merit defence. After thirty-five defence witnesses, the jury returned not guilty on 2 November 1960, and Penguin's 200,000-copy printing sold out on its first day. In America the fight had ended a year earlier, when a federal court struck down the mail ban on Grove Press's 1959 edition.
Paris is where Lawrence beat the pirates. Unauthorized reprints of the Florence edition were selling widely and paying him nothing, so he came to Paris in March 1929, was turned down by Sylvia Beach of Shakespeare and Company, and struck a deal with the bookseller-publisher Edward Titus of 4 rue Delambre: 3,000 copies at 60 francs, with a new introduction, "My Skirmish with Jolly Roger."
The unexpurgated third version — the text of every serious modern edition, including the Penguin Classics edition used here, which follows the Cambridge Lawrence text and adds Lawrence's own essay "A Propos of Lady Chatterley's Lover." The earlier drafts were published separately as The First Lady Chatterley (1944) and John Thomas and Lady Jane (1972).
In the United States, yes — the 1928 novel entered the American public domain on 1 January 2024, and Project Gutenberg released a free complete text (ebook #73144) that March. Copyright terms differ in other countries.