
The Time of the Assassins
The other obsessional study — Rimbaud's he finished; Lawrence's finished him.
Read our take
by Henry Miller
The white whale of the Villa Seurat: the D. H. Lawrence book that nearly swallowed Miller in 1933, published at last in 1980.
In the first flush of the Paris years Miller set out to write a little book on D. H. Lawrence — and fell in. The project ballooned into hundreds of pages, charts pinned to the walls, contradictions he could not resolve, until he abandoned it to save himself; the wreckage sat for nearly half a century before scholars carved a book from it, published by Capra in 1980, the year Miller died. What survived is exactly what its subtitle admits: not criticism but passion — one prophet of the life-force wrestling another, and losing gloriously. (A study — nothing here to spoil.)
The Lawrence obsession was a fever of the early Paris years, and it was shared: Anaïs Nin had just published her own Lawrence study when she and Miller met, and Lawrence — dead in 1930, scandalous as ever — was the ground their endless first conversations kept returning to. Jack Kahane, waiting to publish Tropic of Cancer, actually wanted a Lawrence brochure from Miller first, to dress the house in respectability; the modest assignment detonated. Through 1933 Miller read, charted, and drafted at manic scale — the walls of his workroom papered with schemes and genealogies — as the little book grew into a theory of everything.
It also grew into a crisis: the deeper he went, the more Lawrence's contradictions — and his own — refused to resolve, and the manuscript became the rare project that defeated him; he cut it loose and wrote his own books instead. The hundreds of surviving pages waited until scholars Evelyn J. Hinz and John J. Teunissen edited them into the volume Capra Press published in 1980 — arriving, with terrible neatness, in the year of Miller's death. Read now, it is less a book about Lawrence than the shelf's Rosetta stone: watching Miller define Lawrence's war — body against machine, life-force against civilization — you watch him drafting the creed the Tropics would preach as his own.
The salvaged argument, in movements: Lawrence as the age's sacrificial figure — the artist as scapegoat driven out by the civilization he diagnosed; readings of the novels and the late prophetic books; the war of flesh and machine, sex and will, that Miller takes up as his own; and throughout, the fever of the Villa Seurat years audible under the prose — appreciation at a temperature criticism is not supposed to reach.
Come to it late, after the Tropics: it is the workshop where their doctrine was forged, mislabeled as a book about somebody else.
Every Tropics conviction — flesh against machine, art as life-force — appears here first, hammered out on Lawrence's anvil.
Criticism written at mania's temperature — the wall charts practically show through the prose.
The Nin conversations, the Kahane bargain, the workroom fever — the early Paris years, visible in a single project's rise and collapse.
1933
Commissioned by Jack Kahane to write a respectable Lawrence pamphlet before Tropic of Cancer, Miller instead falls in — reading, charting, and drafting at manic scale through the Villa Seurat years.
1934
The contradictions refuse to resolve; the project becomes the rare one that defeats him, and he cuts it loose to write his own books.
1980
Evelyn J. Hinz and John J. Teunissen edit the surviving pages into a book Capra Press publishes — arriving the year Miller died.

The other obsessional study — Rimbaud's he finished; Lawrence's finished him.
Read our take
The diary's early Paris pages record this very fever — Lawrence was their first shared country.
Read our take
The book he wrote instead — carrying this one's doctrine out of the wreckage.
Read our take
The novel at the center of the obsession — the scandal that made Lawrence the era's test case for what could be printed.
Read our takeHenry Miller. He drafted it in the early 1930s but abandoned it; scholars Evelyn J. Hinz and John J. Teunissen edited the surviving pages into the book Capra Press published in 1980.
Miller's passionate appreciation of D. H. Lawrence — not criticism but one prophet of the life-force wrestling another, body against machine, life against civilization.
The project ballooned out of control in 1933 and defeated him; he cut it loose to write his own books, and the hundreds of surviving pages waited nearly half a century, arriving the year Miller died.
As publisher's window dressing: Jack Kahane wanted a respectable Lawrence pamphlet to precede the scandalous Tropic of Cancer, and got a runaway obsession instead.
It is the workshop where their doctrine was forged — every Tropics conviction appears here first, hammered out on Lawrence's anvil.