The Paris AtlasCharting the artists, works, and places worth returning to.
Cover of For Whom the Bell Tolls by Ernest Hemingway

For Whom the Bell Tolls

by Ernest Hemingway

Three days behind enemy lines in the Spanish mountains — the longest novel, the biggest canvas, and the warmest heart.

Published
1940
Pages
471
Setting
Spain
Shelf rating
4.6

About Ernest Hemingway

Illustrated portrait of Ernest Hemingway

The story, briefly

Spoiler-free

Robert Jordan is an American dynamiter attached to a partisan band in the pine forests above Segovia, ordered to blow a bridge to support a Republican offensive. Over three days — the novel's real time — he falls in love with María, contends with the guerrilla leader Pablo, and comes to terms with what he has been sent to do. Drawn from Hemingway's own time as a war correspondent in Spain, it is his most ambitious novel: the dialogue experiments with Spanish cadences, the cast of partisans is fully alive, and the ending is one of the most formally perfect closings in American fiction.

The story, in more detail

He went to the Spanish Civil War four times as a correspondent between 1937 and 1938, filed dispatches, helped make a propaganda film, and came home with the material for the biggest book he ever attempted: three days, one partisan band, one bridge. He wrote it through 1939 and 1940 in Havana and Sun Valley, took the title from John Donne's meditation — no man is an island — and put an American dynamiter named Robert Jordan in the Guadarrama pines to test the proposition.

Published in October 1940, it was the commercial event of his career: a Book-of-the-Month Club main selection that sold hundreds of thousands of copies within months, a Gary Cooper film deal almost immediately, and a Pulitzer everyone considered settled — until Columbia's president, Nicholas Murray Butler, vetoed the jury and no fiction prize was given at all in 1941.

The politics made everyone angry, which was a kind of proof: the left never forgave the atrocity chapter that showed Republican killings too, or the portrait of the commissar André Marty under his own name, while the right hardly needed reasons. The novel outlasted the arguments — the sleeping-bag romance entered the language, 'the earth moved' became a joke that forgot its source, and the book stands as his longest answer to the question of what dying is worth.

The full plot

What happens, beginning to end — the ending included. Open when you're ready.

Robert Jordan, an American who taught Spanish and now fights for the Spanish Republic as a dynamiter, is sent behind fascist lines with an order: destroy a mountain bridge at the exact hour a Republican offensive begins, three days away. His hosts are a guerrilla band in a cave in the Guadarrama pines — led on paper by Pablo, gone sour and dangerous with self-preservation, and in fact by Pablo's woman Pilar, one of the great characters in American fiction. Among them is Maria, her head still shorn from a fascist prison, with whom Jordan falls in love on the first night.

The three days hold the whole war. Pilar narrates the massacre by which the movement took her town — the novel's most terrible chapter, unsparing toward her own side; the neighboring guerrilla leader El Sordo, caught in open snow, dies with his men on a hilltop under air attack; and a courier carries Jordan's warning through the lines that the offensive is expected and should be canceled — a message that climbs the chain of command exactly too slowly. Pablo, at the worst hour, steals the detonators and deserts; then, unable to live outside the band, comes back with men to help — having drowned the stolen gear anyway.

How it ends — spoilers aheadThe final movement, ending included. Open when you're ready.

The offensive goes ahead, and so does Robert Jordan: he blows the bridge with improvised grenades at the cost of old Anselmo, the gentle hunter who was his best man in the band. In the escape across open ground, a shell takes down Jordan's horse and the fall snaps his left thigh bone. Unable to ride, he orders the survivors on and stays behind with a machine gun to buy them distance — sending Maria away with the argument that she carries him with her now, that as long as one of them lives, both do. The novel ends where it began, with Jordan lying on the pine-needle floor of the forest, heart beating against the ground, waiting for the enemy cavalry officer to enter his sights.

Themes and analysis

These readings discuss events throughout the book, including its ending.

The bridge below the pines

The two men occupy the same hiding place but experience it differently. Jordan welcomes the chance to turn an overwhelming assignment into something he can study, while Anselmo worries that they have come too close. The changing light briefly makes the bridge easier to read, suggesting how dependent their certainty is on passing conditions. Then the field glasses bring the sentry's worn face and ordinary belongings into view. Observation reveals both a problem to solve and a person within it; the mission cannot be reduced to the bridge's structure alone.

Jordan’s assignment begins in observation: the bridge, the road and the time at which they will matter. A literary-scene reconstruction. (Illustration — The Paris Atlas)

The people behind the mission

Pilar's authority emerges through practical questions about the people who must live with the mission's consequences. She notices scarcity in the camp, Pablo's decline and Maria's need to leave. Her welcome does not give Jordan permission to treat those concerns as secondary. When he promises that they will take Maria away if they survive, military uncertainty enters an intimate obligation. Pilar objects to the ominous qualification, but Jordan needs it to make an honest promise. Their exchange gives trust a demanding form: it must acknowledge what neither person can guarantee.

Pilar’s authority and the band’s intimate conversations give the mission its human weight. An interpretive illustration of camp life. (Illustration — The Paris Atlas)

Quotes from For Whom the Bell Tolls

Quoted verbatim from the text, each line verified against its source.

I have fought for what I believed in for a year now. If we win here we will win everywhere. The world is a fine place and worth the fighting for and I hate very much to leave it.
— Robert Jordan (thought) · Ernest Hemingway, For Whom the Bell Tolls (1940)
There is nothing else than now. There is neither yesterday, certainly, nor is there any tomorrow. How old must you be before you know that? There is only now, and if now is only two days, then two days is your life and everything in it will be in proportion.
— Robert Jordan (thought) · Ernest Hemingway, For Whom the Bell Tolls (1940)
Today is only one day in all the days that will ever be. But what will happen in all the other days that ever come can depend on what you do today.
— Robert Jordan (thought) · Ernest Hemingway, For Whom the Bell Tolls (1940)

All 5 For Whom the Bell Tolls quotes →

Why we recommend it

  1. The Pilar chapters

    The old partisan woman Pilar's account of the massacre at the beginning of the war — a set-piece of sustained oral narration that has no equal in Hemingway and few in any language.

  2. The ending

    The last chapter is a masterclass in how to close a long novel — Jordan alone in the pine needles, waiting, and the reader knowing exactly what is coming. The prose does not flinch, and neither can you.

  3. The Spanish experiment

    Hemingway renders Spanish idiom in English throughout, and rather than print the swearing or leave a blank he substitutes the word "obscenity" itself, so a fighter curses as "I obscenity in the milk of thy tiredness." Critics mocked the decision at the time; it now reads as respectful and oddly moving.

What this book explores

The people in its pages

  • Illustrated portrait of Robert Jordan

    Robert Jordan

    An American who teaches Spanish at a university in Montana and blows up bridges for the Spanish Republic. He is given one bridge and three days.

  • Illustrated portrait of Pilar

    Pilar

    Pablo's wife, and the person the guerrilla band actually obeys. She is forty-eight, she lived nine years with bullfighters, and she tells the longest and most terrible story in the book.

  • Illustrated portrait of Maria

    Maria

    A young Spanish woman the band pulled off a wrecked prison train three months before the novel starts. Her hair is growing back from a prison shave.

  • Illustrated portrait of Pablo

    Pablo

    The guerrilla leader who has stopped wanting to fight. He killed on a scale nobody in the band has forgotten, and now cares mainly about his horses.

  • Illustrated portrait of Anselmo

    Anselmo

    The sixty-eight-year-old hunter who guides Robert Jordan in and stays with him to the end. He believes killing a man is a sin, and does it when he is told to.

  • Illustrated portrait of El Sordo

    El Sordo

    The leader of the second guerrilla band in the mountains north of Madrid. His name is Santiago; everyone calls him the deaf one.

  • Illustrated portrait of Karkov

    Karkov

    A Soviet journalist in Madrid and one of the most powerful men in Republican Spain. Robert Jordan learned how the war actually worked by listening to him.

  • Illustrated portrait of Agustín

    Agustín

    A guerrilla in Pablo's band who swears in every sentence, works the automatic rifle, and is the first person to warn Robert Jordan what Pablo will do.

Also in the book

  • Illustrated portrait of Rafael

    Rafael

    The gypsy in Pablo's band. A very good talker, a passable shot, and completely unreliable for an hour at a time.

  • Illustrated portrait of Fernando

    Fernando

    A guerrilla in Pablo's band who does not joke, disapproves of most things, and walks to the market town to sit in cafés and listen.

  • Illustrated portrait of Joaquín

    Joaquín

    An eighteen-year-old in El Sordo's band. He was training to be a bullfighter until the war, and his family were shot in Valladolid.

  • Illustrated portrait of Andrés

    Andrés

    A guerrilla in Pablo's band who is sent through the lines with a message, and spends the last night of the novel trying to get anyone to take it.

Real people in this book

The real people this book portrays, dedicates itself to, or draws from — every connection carries its source.

Illustrated portrait of Martha Gellhorn

Martha Gellhorn

  • Journalist
  • Author

Dedicated to · 1940

They had reported Spain together, and the novel came out of it. The dedication is printed in the book; the marriage lasted five years.

— Ernest Hemingway Collection — Martha Gellhorn (Hemingway) | EH@JFK, John F. Kennedy Presidential Library

Depicts · 1940

Not a portrait. The JFK Library's account gives Maria her appearance, and divides her strength, toughness and loyalty between Maria and Pilar — and adds that Pilar is a composite who also owes much to Gertrude Stein. Gellhorn and Hemingway had reported the Spanish Civil War together, and that shared work is what the novel is built out of.

— Ernest Hemingway Collection — Martha Gellhorn (Hemingway) | EH@JFK, John F. Kennedy Presidential Library

The real history

Hemingway covered the Spanish Civil War for the North American Newspaper Alliance from 1937 to 1938, filing dispatches from Madrid under bombardment and was present at the Battle of the Ebro — most of what Jordan knows, Hemingway learned at first hand.

From the Journal

Stories from the atlas that shelve this book.

Real history

Scott and Ernest: A Friendship in Five Rounds

Fitzgerald vouched for Hemingway before he'd met him and edited him better than he edited himself. Hemingway outlived him and wrote the eulogy crooked. The friendship, round by round.

Adriana Pope · · 9 min read

Bring it to book club

  • Jordan knows from early on that the mission is likely pointless. Does his decision to carry it out anyway read as heroism, duty, or something else?
  • Pilar is arguably the most fully realized character in all of Hemingway. What does she do that his male protagonists don't?
  • The novel uses a single weekend as its frame but spans an entire war in its flashbacks. How does the compression affect what it can say about the Spanish Civil War?

A complete discussion guide is on our editorial calendar. Join the letter to hear when it ships.

Timeline

  1. 1937–1938

    Hemingway covers the Spanish Civil War four times as a correspondent.

  2. 1939–1940

    He writes the novel in Havana and Sun Valley, taking the title from John Donne.

  3. 1940

    Scribner publishes it in October; a Book-of-the-Month Club main selection, it sells hundreds of thousands within months.

  4. 1941

    Columbia's president vetoes the Pulitzer jury's choice, and no fiction prize is given that year.

Book editions

Hardcover
Hardcover
Scribner
1940
First edition
Paperback edition cover
Paperback
Scribner
1995
ISBN-13
9780684803357
Ebook edition cover
Ebook
Scribner
ISBN-13
9780743237178
Audiobook
Audiobook

Reader reviews

Loading reviews…

Cover of A Farewell to Arms by Ernest Hemingway

A Farewell to Arms

Ernest Hemingway

The earlier war novel: where that one ends in private defeat, this one ends in political defeat on the same scale.

Read our take

Recommended alongside Across the River and into the Trees, I Wonder as I Wander, The Face of War, The Fifth Column and the First Forty-Nine Stories and The Spanish Earth.

Also recommended in books like A Farewell to Arms.

For Whom the Bell Tolls: frequently asked questions

Who wrote For Whom the Bell Tolls?

Ernest Hemingway. Published in 1940, it is his longest and most ambitious novel.

What is For Whom the Bell Tolls about?

Robert Jordan, an American dynamiter attached to a partisan band in the mountains above Segovia during the Spanish Civil War, is ordered to blow a bridge. Over three days he falls in love with María and contends with the guerrilla leader Pablo.

Is For Whom the Bell Tolls based on real events?

It draws on Hemingway's four trips to the Spanish Civil War as a correspondent between 1937 and 1938, when he filed dispatches and helped make a propaganda film.

Where does the title come from?

From a meditation by the poet John Donne — "never send to know for whom the bell tolls; it tolls for thee" — which Hemingway quotes as the book's epigraph.

Why is it considered his most ambitious novel?

For its experiments with Spanish-inflected dialogue, its fully realized cast of partisans, and a closing regarded as one of the most formally perfect in American fiction.

If you like Ernest Hemingway

Explore authors with a similar voice, perspective, and influence.

  • Illustrated portrait of Louis-Ferdinand Céline

    Louis-Ferdinand Céline

    The other great stylist the Great War produced — where Hemingway cut the language down, Céline set it on fire. The same wound, opposite treatments.

    View author
  • Illustrated portrait of Henry Miller

    Henry Miller

    Paris on no money a decade later, with the restraint removed. Miller called Hemingway's Paris a tourist's Paris; readers get to referee.

    View author
  • Illustrated portrait of Martha Gellhorn

    Martha Gellhorn

    War correspondent who covered the Spanish Civil War, D-Day, and conflicts across five more decades; Hemingway's third wife, 1940–1945.

    View author

Places in this book

Places you can enter today appear first, followed by addresses to see from outside and sites that have vanished.

References

References

The sources below include the primary text, editions, scholarship, archival materials, and other records that informed this page. They document For Whom the Bell Tolls, its publication, and its place in literary history.

  1. 1For Whom the Bell Tolls

    Novel
    Ernest Hemingway, 1940
    Used for

    The primary text represented by this page, used for descriptions of the work’s contents and for any quoted passages shown here.

  2. 2For Whom the Bell Tolls — public text

    Website
    Faded Page / Distributed Proofreaders Canada, 2021
    Used for

    Public 2021 transcription of a Blakiston printing bearing the 1940 copyright; exact printing date not established. Analysis uses chapter Three's opening reconnaissance and chapter Two's first conversation with Pilar. No whole-novel or original-edition collation.

    View source
  3. 3Ernest Hemingway House National Register Nomination

    Official record
    National Park Service, 1968
    Used for

    The National Park Service nomination cautiously documents that Hemingway likely wrote part of the novel at his Key West home.

    View source
  4. 4Ernest Hemingway Collection — Martha Gellhorn (Hemingway) | EH@JFK, John F. Kennedy Presidential Library

    Website
    John F. Kennedy Presidential Library and Museum
    Used for

    Web source consulted for documented facts and historical context presented on the For Whom the Bell Tolls page.

    View source
  1. 5Ernest Hemingway: A Life Story

    Biography
    Carlos Baker, 1969
    Used for

    Biographical evidence used to verify chronology, relationships, and historical context connected to For Whom the Bell Tolls.

  2. 6Max Perkins: Editor of Genius

    Biography
    E. P. Dutton, 1978
    Used for

    Biographical evidence used to verify chronology, relationships, and historical context connected to For Whom the Bell Tolls.

  3. 7Ernest Hemingway, The Art of Fiction No. 21

    Periodical
    The Paris Review, Issue 18, Spring 1958, 1958
    Used for

    Used to verify Ernest Hemingway's bibliography and place For Whom the Bell Tolls within the broader chronology of Ernest Hemingway's career.

    View source
i
Why these sources are here

The primary text is the baseline reference for every book page. Additional references document publication history, interpretation, and historical context where that evidence is available.

Explore more resources