
A Moveable Feast
How Gertrude appears in its pages: Hostess of 27 rue de Fleurus, where he was instructed on writing, painting, and much else — and the relay for the epigraph's 'lost generation.'
Hostess of 27 rue de Fleurus, where he was instructed on writing, painting, and much else — and the relay for the epigraph's 'lost generation.'
Who they are in the book
Spoiler-freeMiss Stein holds court beneath the Cézannes and Picassos at 27 rue de Fleurus, and the book's young narrator walks over whenever the work allows — for the eau-de-vie, the pictures, and the instruction. She teaches him what to look at and what to cut, tells him to buy paintings instead of clothes, and hands the era its name by relaying a garage owner's complaint about the war generation: they are all a lost generation, she says, and he puts it at the front of a novel.
What she wants, in the memoir's sharp-eyed telling, is recognition on her own terms — publication in the big magazines, official standing to match her private authority — and loyalty from the young men she instructs. The portrait gives her real brilliance and real warmth before it gives her anything else; the friendship is one of the book's pleasures while it lasts.
How the book draws them
- The presenceBig without being tall, dressed like a peasant matriarch from the north of Italy, with a mobile face, beautiful eyes, and thick living hair worn up — until the famous crop that left it looking Roman and imperial.
- The talkA monologuist of genius: the visits run on her voice, and the young narrator mostly pours the eau-de-vie and listens.
- The house rulesThe salon had commandments — admire the pictures, accept the instruction, and mention Joyce twice and you would not be asked back.
- The vocabularyHer verdicts arrive in collector's terms: an early story is dismissed as the kind of painting no dealer could hang — unshowable, whatever its other virtues.
- The roomOne of the warmest places in Paris: the big stove, the cakes, the fruit brandies poured without stinting, and walls that amounted to a private museum of modern painting.
- The garage storyThe era's name arrives secondhand: a garage owner's rebuke to a slow young mechanic — a lost generation, all of them — relayed by Stein and enlarged into a verdict on everyone who'd been to the war.
At a glance
- 'Miss Stein' — salon hostess, collector, and writing instructor
- 'Miss Stein Instructs,' 'Une Génération Perdue,' and 'A Strange Enough Ending'
- Gertrude Stein · 1874–1946 · Allegheny, Pennsylvania — raised in Oakland, California
'A Strange Enough Ending' is exactly that: the friendship ends not with an argument but with something overheard. Calling at the rue de Fleurus one morning, Hemingway hears Stein's companion speaking to her upstairs as he has never heard one person speak to another, and Stein pleading in reply. He leaves without seeing her, and the book says the friendship was never the same. The companion goes unnamed in the chapter; she was Alice B. Toklas, who outlived Stein by twenty-one years.
The break was mutual and public in real life — Stein mocked Hemingway's toughness in The Autobiography of Alice B. Toklas in 1933, and the memoir's portrait, written after her death in 1946, is his last word in a quarrel that ran three decades. Readers should weigh both versions: each writer claimed to have taught the other, and neither account is disinterested.




























