The Paris AtlasCharting the artists, works, and places worth returning to.
Illustrated portrait of Mr Toagis

A character in A Clergyman's Daughter

Mr Toagis

A surly retired market gardener whose attachment to the Church rested entirely on the privilege of decorating a window at the Harvest Festival. He grew a monstrous pumpkin for it, was in raptures over it, could not tear himself away and kept bringing friends to admire it, and when it was removed he went over to chapel, taking his heirs with him for ever.

What they want

To have his vegetables displayed in the church at Harvest Festival. It is the one thing that keeps him in the congregation, and he loses interest in the Church the moment it is taken away.

The book

Cover of A Clergyman's Daughter by George Orwell
A Clergyman's DaughterGeorge Orwell, 1935

Orwell's second novel: a rector's daughter loses her memory, wakes up on a London street, and finds out what England does with a penniless woman.

View the book

At a glance

In the book
A parishioner of St Athelstan's, Knype Hill
Trade
Market gardener, retired
What he grew for the church
Giant marrows, and one very large red pumpkin
How his story is told
In one passage, after the fact; he never appears in a scene
Where he appears
Chapter 1

Who they are in the book

Spoiler-free

Mr Toagis is a character in A Clergyman's Daughter, the 1935 novel by George Orwell. He is a retired market gardener in Knype Hill, the small Suffolk town where the book opens, and he was a parishioner of St Athelstan's, the church run by the Reverend Charles Hare, father of the book's central character, Dorothy Hare.

He never appears on the page. The whole of his story is told in one short passage in the first chapter, as an example of the damage the Rector does by being unable to hide his contempt for parish life. Dorothy raises the Harvest Festival at breakfast, her father says he is not a greengrocer and does not enjoy preaching among festoons of runner beans, and the story of Mr Toagis follows as the thing that came of that attitude.

By instinct he belonged in a Nonconformist chapel, and George Orwell says as much in Latin -- anima naturaliter Nonconformistica, a naturally Nonconformist soul. What kept him in the Church of England was one annual privilege: at Harvest Festival he was allowed to dress the side altar with his own produce, which he did with a sort of Stonehenge of giant vegetable marrows.

How the book draws them

Appearance, manner, and tone — as the book sketches them, in our words.

  • What he wasA retired market gardener, described in one word as surly, and counted by the Rector as a valuable parishioner -- meaning one who paid.
  • What kept him in the churchThe right to decorate the side altar at Harvest Festival. He built a sort of Stonehenge out of gigantic vegetable marrows. Nothing else about the Church of England held him.
  • The pumpkinThe previous summer he grew a fiery red pumpkin so enormous that it took two men to lift it. It was set down in the chancel, where it dwarfed the altar and took all the colour out of the east window. Wherever in the church you stood, it hit you in the eye.
  • How he behaved about itHe was in raptures. He hung about the church at all hours, unable to tear himself away, and brought relays of friends in to admire it. George Orwell writes that from the look on his face you would have thought he was reciting Wordsworth's sonnet on Westminster Bridge, and prints three lines of it.
  • What Dorothy hopedThat the pumpkin might be the way in. After it she had hopes of getting him to come to Holy Communion.
  • What ended itThe Rector saw the pumpkin, was seriously angry, and ordered that revolting thing removed at once. Mr Toagis went chapel immediately, and he and his heirs were lost to the church for ever.